Marxism as the opiate of the masses: how so-called “revolutionary” communism hurts the left

5–7 minutes

You have probably seen their posters and stickers peppered around Halifax, bearing slogans like End the Billionaire Class, Class War Now! and Join the Revolution! Perhaps you have even seen the Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP) in person at one of their many “tabling” events, where they sell Marxist literature and copies of their periodical newspaper. Maybe you have even stopped to talk with them, or been curious enough, as I was, to attend one of their tri-weekly meetings in the Dalhousie Student Union Building. 

 

But what is the RCP? Apart from calling each other ‘comrade’ and distributing leaflets, what do they do? The short answer: nothing. For a “party” that calls itself “revolutionary,” the RCP has no interest in any formal political action, nor starting any revolutions — it might be better described as a Marxist book club rather than a political organization. 

 

Nevertheless, membership rates for the RCP continue to grow, and as they scale up recruitment operations — especially on university campuses — it is becoming increasingly imperative that people understand the risks they pose, particularly to the Canadian left-wing. 

 

A division of the Revolutionary Communist International, the RCP is dedicated to “creating a steeled vanguard” of stalwart revolutionaries. The RCP promises prospective inductees that if members dedicate themselves fully to the party, the party will be chosen to lead the post-revolutionary world when the working class inevitably revolts against the capitalist class.

 

Perceiving the revolution as an inevitable event is the symptom of an all-too-common misreading of Marx as prophesizing the end of capitalism, and the triumph of communism as the unavoidable culmination of dialectical-historical progress. The consequence of this fatalist utopianism is that it disincentivizes people from working to change their current circumstances, while encouraging the working class to wait quietly for the world to change around them. 

 

To this effect, as they told me in a meeting in June, the RCP is a ‘non-accelerationist’ organization. In other words, the party is not concerned with instigating revolution. 

 

The RCP is also unconcerned with alleviating the present living conditions of the working class.

 

As explained to me by a current member, the RCP is opposed to all forms of direct action. When asked why, the same member told me that charity keeps poor people less angry, and so less likely to revolt. In a sense, I believe they would rather starve the poor until revolution becomes the only way out.

 

I was also told that other political organizations who have dedicated themselves to charity have lost sight of their revolutionary goals. Pushed for an example, the member then told me that “if the Black Panther Party had dedicated more of its resources to political strategizing and fewer to direct action programs, maybe they would have succeeded.” 

 

The program to which the member was alluding was the Free Breakfast for Children Program, operated across the United States beginning in 1969 to provide free food to children living in poverty before school, foster relationships between the Panthers and struggling (largely Black) communities, and combat rising food insecurity. The program coincided with other initiatives like community schools and clinics providing free, high-quality education and medical care to poor communities. 

 

By the party’s accounts, the program fed hundreds of thousands of children. By all accounts, it was a success. 

 

So, if the RCP is opposed both to programs which “distract” from revolutionary aims as well as the taking of any action to “accelerate” revolution, then what exactly do they do? 

 

They are certainly not short of resources. Last year they brought in almost two million dollars nationally, with expectations to do the same again this year. Most of this money comes from member dues, charged at a minimum rate of one day’s salary per month (a prohibitively high $140/month at Halifax’s current minimum wage, with many members paying in excess of $200/month). 

 

With almost 900 members, that becomes around $150,000/month from dues alone. The rest comes from the bi-annual fundraisers organized by the party, as well as profits from their periodical newspaper and book sales. Members are also expected to work hours equivalent to a part-time job for the party — and with membership projections exceeding 1000 members by 2027, manpower is clearly not an issue. 

 

When I asked what the RCP does with its resources, the only concrete expenses I was able to ascertain were the monthly rent for the party’s Toronto headquarters (for which they ran a $250,000 fundraiser in April  2024), and the yearly salaries of ‘professional revolutionaries’: individuals whose “usefulness to the revolutionary cause is inhibited by their needing to work other jobs.” Again, we might wonder, “what cause?” 

 

The RCP has 18 such revolutionaries on payroll. By contrast, the NDP, a party which received over 1 million votes last federal election, holds seven seats in parliament, and has over 100,000 registered members, has 17 full time staff. 

 

While the RCP’s high dues are ostensibly enforced to ensure that members are committed to the cause, they separate the RCP from the working class. After all, how many working class people do you know who can afford in excess of $100/month and a 10-15 hour weekly commitment — at minimum wage, approximately $1000 in unpaid work per month? 

 

Additionally, these costs act as tethers which make leaving the party difficult. 

 

I spoke to one member who had been in the party for six years and was paying more than $200 per month. By my calculations, she had spent in excess of $12,000 and sacrificed over 4000 hours of her time. A ‘sunk-cost’ mindset can make cutting one’s losses by leaving the party difficult, especially when many members also come to rely on the party for their social relationships.

 

I do not mean to make it seem like members of the RCP are insidious or stupid. The people I met were among the most well-spoken, well-read, intelligent people I have had the pleasure of speaking with. My principal concern is that these people, those most inclined towards and capable of fighting for change, are being wasted in the RCP, an organization which has nothing to show for its 27 years of activity. 

 

To those in the RCP: Get out before you waste your time and money. Go volunteer somewhere, engage on a direct level with the community. Nobody will follow you into communism if you don’t show them what communist action looks like. As you have yourselves acknowledged, many Canadians are with you. I am with you. But we cannot follow you to nowhere.


Read the latest:

Exit mobile version