The Watch List: winner of Cannes Film Festival

4–5 minutes

This year’s Palme d’Or winner at the Cannes Film Festival was Fjord (2026), the second movie by Romanian director Cristian Mungiu to win the festival’s most prestigious film award. Fjord stars Renate Reinsve and Sebastian Stan as Lisbet and Mihai, a couple who immigrate from Romania to a remote village in Norway, hoping to start a new life near Lisbet’s family. 

The family struggles to assimilate to Norwegian culture, mainly because of their conservative evangelical Christianity. Mihai awkwardly plays hymns on the staff room piano; Lisbet, working in a nursing home, secretly attempts to convert her patients. But their children have the most difficulty adjusting, as they have been raised without internet, and taught that homosexuality is a sin 一 red flags for their watchful, secular teachers. 

When a gym teacher notices bruises on the oldest daughter’s arms and neck, she admits that her parents beat her. Child Protection Services is quickly involved and the children are separated from their parents. The rest of the film focuses on the parents’ fight to assert their religious freedom and regain custody of their kids. 

Mihai’s defence is that in his culture, both Romanian custom and his version of Christianity, a certain level of physical punishment is acceptable, even encouraged, as discipline. But this is Norway, where that isn’t allowed. Fjord presents itself as a nuanced critique of the kind of progressive Western government that sounds great on paper but, through kafkaesque bureaucracy and rigid authoritarianism, acts as a kind of filter for cultural difference, preying on well-meaning but disoriented immigrants who just want to be left alone. 

In an interview with The Film Stage, Mungiu said that no matter how tolerant or inclusive a society claims to be, a majority will always impose a point of view upon the minority.

Don’t get me wrong 一 this is a real, systemic problem. Western liberal democracies use bureaucracy to uphold desired racial, sexual, and ethnic norms all the time. Canada has a long history of  indirectly and directly alienating immigrants and other groups who fail to conform to a particular definition of “civilized.” 

In fact, the film is based on a real Romanian family whose children were taken into custody by Norwegian CPS in 2015, after their daughter told her teacher she was slapped. The real parents, like Mihai and Lisbet in Fjord, admitted to spanking their children without knowing it was illegal in Norway. News outlets around the world reported on the case as a damning example of government overreach at best and religious discrimination at worst. 

By making us empathize with the conservative Christian family, Mungiu wants to challenge liberal audiences’ assumption that moral institutions act ethically without exception, and that there is a clear line between personal freedom and what necessitates state intervention. 

The problem is that nothing that happens in Fjord is real. Every morally grey dilemma faced is a construct within the movie. The whole thing is a straw man fallacy: an exaggerated, fabricated version of the real problem — one that is not only counter-productive, but actively harmful.

The way CPS behaves in this film is outlandish to the point of caricature. Government officials are portrayed as austere, ruthless suits just itching to take the children away from these poor, befuddled immigrants. The children are placed in separate foster homes, a measure that in real life is only done as a last resort, when children are believed to pose a risk to each other. In the film, the official simply says that “biological bonds carry no weight,” an astounding claim that no social worker would ever realistically believe. 

There are countless other examples, but one especially absurd moment happens when, discussing the terms of the family being reunited, CPS tells Lisbet that she’ll have to become a stay-at-home mom in order to smooth the transition. This is an appalling reinforcement of the patriarchy, and is clearly the opposite of what a mother would be told to do in this situation. And what’s the argument here? Is CPS too woke, or is it so backward that it instructs women to quit their jobs? 

Why would Mungiu portray such an important, under-appreciated liberal institution in such an unfair, outlandish way? Surely to put a finger on the scale, to manipulate the audience into siding – for a couple hours, anyway – with the abusive family. 

Mungiu constructs a fictional world in order to be able to play both sides, but the film is a two-hour dogwhistle for anti-woke politics. There is nothing morally ambiguous about this story so long as you take a step back from what it’s forcibly showing you. It’s not one family against the Leviathan; it’s a man abusing his children and the audience being manipulated into vague empathy. 

Fjord is a controversial movie worth seeing to form your own opinion, so I guess it accomplished its goal. But it’s certainly not the elevated critique of Western society touted at Cannes. It’s just conservative propaganda, pushing exactly the repressive, conspiratorial agenda that undermines the legitimacy of crucial institutions that save real children from from real abuse.


Read the latest:

Exit mobile version